What is making me nervous here is after the shambolic performance of the Genesis '2nd year gift' (in my case something which I failed to down load) whether or not any thing substantial will come from the PC fan club.

Yes, it's is interesting looking at the odd video (once) and I have the But Seriously dvd so do not need a see that.

The pictures are interesting to glance through when they are loaded .. but again I will look at them once.

The thing that has longevity is some decent audio down loads. We where promised these in some form or another from the Genesis fan club (remember teh sound board project) and I had hoped for something similar fron here. To date, at least, there has been little activity on this front.

I appreciate it is early days but after the way the Genesis fan club members where treated with their promised 'gift' I am just nervous that this is going the same way. I am happy to contribute to Phil's retirement fund but would like a reasonable amount back in return for my hard earned cash.

I guess the debate is what is reasonable ? At the moment, for me at least, the jury is firmly out !

Mat

The Fan Club content is decided on a month-by-month basis with us, Phil and his management, and what the future holds is never certain until it is on the site, so I cannot say either way as to whether or not there will be any more audio material soon. However, there will defintely be more, but only when Phil and his management give us some.

Regards,

Louis.

After all, phil is a musician, and its pretty odd that you promise audio material and then we aren't getting any stuff. Another thing, which is odd is that phil has huge collection tapes and almost any of those would be interesting to hear, still nothing comes up. Webmasters; you could even tell honestly that this fanclub thing, doesn't gonna contain any bootlegs, unfortunately. That would be fair to everybody, especially those who were at the genesis-fanclub.

and the December audio content, as of today, is the same as the Nov and Oct audio content - a young Phil drumming .. not impressed guys !

Could you answer (webmaster), why any audio material isn't coming to the fanclub?

We have a large collection of stuff we are saving for the December load, but as it stands we're not sure exactly what will make the cut, but rest assued more audio is on it's way!

The official bootleg idea is a good one, which I will suggest and see what we can do!

Now we know what the November content is. You did show the picture of Phil's archive "audio" tapes, is there coming any material, soon?

It would have been great idea to include more details to the "song additions", like demo versions of the songs.

More content is added on a month-by-month basis, and now that November is here, more content should be made available soon!